Between our honeymoon, vacation in May and living here since September, Sarah and I have visited nearly 50 non-major chain restaurants in Boston and the surrounding area. We still haven’ t hit Eagle’s Deli in Brighton or the Union Oyster House near Faneuil Hall, but here’s our top 10 restaurants in Boston.
1. Black Rose Pub- Boston has several dozen Irish pubs, and out of the 20 we’ve been to, the Black Rose Pub on State Street near the Custom House is the best. The menu isn’t anything too beyond what you would find in most Irish pubs or just an ordinanary bar (hamburgers, fish & chips, reubens), it’s just the best of its kind in Boston. On top of the quality of the food, the beer selection is diverse enough and the atmosphere is awesome. The staff is all very friendly, and some are even from Ireland. With dark coloring, wood finishes, Irish flags, there’s definitely the feel of a quality pub. Irish bands and singer play the occasional night job; plus, you’ve got to love a place that features rugby on TV.
2. Ma Soba- Other sushi places in Boston are rated higher by the official mags and whatnot, but Ma Soba on Cambridge Street is our favorite. The restaurant offers quality rolls, including fish-free and cooked rolls, which is great when Sarah can’t eat raw fish because she’s pregnant. There’s a very modern atmosphere, even if the open tables are a little too close to other diners. We recommend the Gari Gari Roll, particularly because of the cream cheese.
3. Giacomo’s – This Italian restaurant on the North End’s Hanover Street is small; you’ve got to wait in line outside for a table to open up – rain, sun or freezing cold – and the place is crowded inside with just enough room to sit and eat. What you’ll find inside, though, is the best Italian food you’ve ever had. The menu isn’t terribly complicated, and the prices are low considering what you’re paying for. It’s well worth the wait.
4. Burton’s Grill- It’s a steakhouse with mouth-watering, delicious food that is hard to believe. Burton’s Grill has four locations in New England, but we went to the one near Fenway Park in Boston. The steak is all we’ve had but better than anything found in an Outback or Longhorn steakhouse. To boot, there’s a nice, dark, cozy and romantic atmosphere in Burton’s, making it a great spot for a date.
5. Mike’s Pastry- Pound-for-pound, this is the best food in Boston; the only issue is it’s all desserts. Also on North End’s Hanover Street, about a block from Giacomo’s, Mike’s has more tasty treats than anyone could ever hope for: canolis, lobster tails, black and white cookies, rum cakes, cheesecake, Boston cream pie and plenty more. If you’re having dinner anywhere near the North End, skip dessert at the restaurant and head to Mike’s. It’ll be slightly cheaper and 10 times better. There’s a long line to get to the counter, but it moves fast and the food is well worth it.
6. Souper Salad- This lunch spot has multiple locations throughout Boston, but our favorite is on Berkeley Street near Boston Public Garden. We get our food to go and eat in the garden by the squirrels and ducks and whatnot. The lunch menu is diverse, but we always get the walkabouts, which is a salad-sandwich wrap of sorts; Sarah’s favorite is the Buffalo chicken, and mine is the Bostonian, which has the turkey dinner wrapped inside it. Souper Salad isn’t open past 5 p.m. or on the weekends, so make sure you stop by during a day trip to the city.
7. M.J. O’Connor’s – Two locations in Boston, in the Park Plaza hotel near the Public Garden and on the waterfront in South Boston. This is our other favorite Irish pub in the city; and the food is a bit more Gaelic than at the Black Rose. The appetizers are the best. It has more of a bar atmosphere than a restaurant, but layout and lighting fit the mood just fine.
8. McCormick & Schmick’s - OK, it’s not a New England-exclusive restaurant or even based out of Boston, but the first time we went to this upscale chain was at Fanueil Hall, so it’s Boston for us. Very few steak and seafood restaurants actually pull off both types of food with excellence, but McCormick & Schmick’s does it with flying colors.
9. Fire & Ice- Call it Mongolian barbeque or grille buffet, there’s nothing quite as satisfying as an all-you-can-eat place where diners can fill up on multiple plates of dinners they put together themselves and are grilled before their eyes. Fire & Ice stands out because of its wide meat and vegetable selection, and the music playing over the loudspeaker is perfect for people who grew up in the 90s. The best part is, if you start eating before 4 p.m., your meal only costs $10.
10. Sprinkles- It’s just a little ice cream stand at the end of Quincy Market in Faneuil Hall; but they cover their soft serve with sprinkles, and it’s nothing short of magic. When you go, make sure you have the scooper put sprinkles on the bottom of your cup or cone before putting ice cream in it. Then, get sprinkles on top; and when you eat your ice cream, there’s a bonus, double sprinkles on the bottom!